"Not everything that is faced can be changed, but nothing can be changed until it is faced." - James Baldwin
Just as the murder of George Floyd was a watershed moment in the ongoing pursuit of racial and equal justice, so too was last week’s guilty verdict in the Derek Chauvin trial. Keith Ellison, the Attorney General of Minnesota, called the verdict “accountability, which is the first step towards justice.” President Biden noted, “So we can’t leave this moment or look away, thinking our work is done… We have a chance to begin to change the trajectory in this country.”
Despite the guilty verdict, we know George Floyd’s death is not an isolated tragedy. The continued police shootings of people of color reminds us that law too often continues to be enforced and applied differently depending upon the color of one’s skin. See Professor Reggie Oh’s recent column in the Washington Monthly, Geography Helped Kill George Floyd
So what’s our role in being part of the solution?
On June 11, 2020, I issued our Call to Action to address racial and social justice, and antiracism. We created the CSU C|M|LAW Social Justice and Antiracism Resources Guide, CSU C|M|LAW No Room for Silence, and CSU C|M|LAW Anti-Asian Racism- We Stand in Solidarity webpages that includes relevant messages and statements.
Most importantly, we formed the C|M|LAW Racial Justice Task Force consisting of students, faculty, staff, and alumni to ensure that we implement our Call to Action. We formed four Racial Justice Work Groups: School Climate, Training and Education, Public Action, and Community Conversations.
I am very grateful for the excellent work of our four Racial Justice Work Groups.
Below are their 2020-21 Reports which will be posted on our website later today. Each Work Group is co-chaired by a student, a staff member, and a faculty member.
I want to especially thank our 12 Co-Chairs who have been true JEDI (Justice, Equity, Diversity, Inclusion) Warriors:
School Climate Work Group Co-Chairs: Tayler Gill ’22, Sarah Beznoska, Assistant Dean for Student/Career Services, Professor April Cherry
Training/ Education Work Group Co-Chairs: Davona Mason ‘22, Laura Ray, Outreach & Instructional Services Librarian, Professor Matthew Green
Public Action Work Group Co-Chairs: Brandy Davis ‘22, Beth Farrell, Head of Library Access/Technical Services, Professor Ken Kowalski
Community Conversations Work Group Co-Chairs: Chuka Anyafo ‘22, Amy Miller, Director of Alumni & Donor Relations /Associate Director for Enrollment, Professor Pam Daiker-Middaugh
School Climate Work Group
Co-Chairs: Tayler Gill ’22 , Sarah Beznoska, Assistant Dean for Student/Career Services, Professor April Cherry
Charge: Create a more inclusive and supportive environment at C|M|LAW.
2020-21 Progress Report
- Determined that data would be needed to make decisions about student experience and school climate
- Breonna Taylor Teach-In: Say Her Name (organized by Professor April Cherry and moderated by student co-chair Tayler Gill ) featuring legal experts Professor Jonathan Witmer-Rich and Professor Reggie Oh.
- Student-Only Discussion (moderated by student co-chair Tayler Gill ): Students were given the opportunity to speak openly and candidly on their feelings of school climate.
- Law Student Survey of Student Engagement (LSSSE) Survey: Asst. Dean Sarah Beznoska partnered with LSSSE to have a survey administered to the entire student body with an added module surveying DEI issues. We are hoping to analyze that data towards the end of the academic year/over the summer.
- Community Conversation: Race & Law: Capitol Insurrection vs. BLM Protests (Professor April Cherry worked in collaboration with Community Conversation Work Group) featuring Professor Ayesha Bell Hardaway (Case Law), Professor Reggie Oh, and Christopher McNeal ‘16, Counsel for Cleveland BLM
- Faculty/Staff DEI Training: Work with the Training and Education Work Group to bring in a third-party source for training.
- Center for Advocacy and Student Equity (CASE): CASE will be a “center” where students can report any incidences of inequity or other prejudicial issues at C|M|LAW. Students typically refrain from reporting said issues because they are afraid of the consequences they may suffer if they decide to report the wrong to a higher authority. We are currently working with OIE to figure out how to best implement this idea.
- Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) Pledge: Student co-chair Tayler Gill drafted a DEI pledge that will be distributed to the entire school on behalf of the Racial Justice Task Force. All students, faculty, and staff will be strongly encouraged to take this pledge. Working with Associate Dean Carolyn Broering-Jacobs on implementing this pledge (and other racial justice events) into the 1L orientation this upcoming August.
Training and Education Work Group
Co-Chairs: Davona Mason ‘22, Laura Ray, Outreach & Instructional Services Librarian, Professor Matthew Green
Charge: Develop training and education around bias, cultural competence, and anti-racism for students, faculty, and staff.
2020-2021 Progress Report
- Researched and identified third-party organizations to assist with customizing a training program for students, faculty and staff at C|M|LAW to address such issues as bias, racism and cultural competence. Solicited proposals from three organizations engaged in education and training: Enlightened Solutions, the Anti-Defamation League and the Racial Equity Institute; Met with and interviewed associates of Enlightened Solutions and the Anti-Defamation League; and with the Social Climate Work Group and the Diversity Council, reviewed proposals and recommended to Dean Lee Fisher that C|M|LAW hire Enlightened Solutions to develop and implement a long-term training program addressing issues of bias, racism and cultural competence, among others.
- Researched and identified third-party organizations to provide anti-bias training to incoming 1Ls during student orientation. Recommended the law school hire Defex Online: https://thedefamationexperience.com/defex-online/.
- Explored implementing a diversity and inclusion training program that could be available to students, faculty and staff in the late spring 2021 semester and through the summer. Researched programs and selected the “21-day challenge,” a program that provides participants with resources (readings, podcasts, videos, and seminars) aimed at providing a deeper understanding of racism, bias and social justice and encourages participants to record their thoughts/impressions of the resources they review; Dean Fisher formed a subcommittee to design and tailor the program for C|M|LAW: Laura Ray, Professor Pamela Daiker-Middaugh, Taylor Gill, Sarah Beznoska and Beth Farrell.
- Uploaded the 21-Day Challenge to the C|M|LAW Social Justice & Antiracism Resource Guide: https://guides.law.csuohio.edu/SocialJusticeAntiRacism
- Work with and support efforts of the 3rd party organization the law school ultimately hires to develop and implement training around issues of bias, racism and cultural competence. Coordinate with Associate Dean Carolyn Broering-Jacobs to gather student feedback on 1L diversity and inclusion orientation programming. With the Diversity Council, explore inviting diverse alumni to join the Diversity Council to gain additional perspectives from integral stakeholders on how to improve the law school climate for diversity and inclusion for students, faculty and staff. With the Diversity Council, explore ways to incorporate issues of social awareness and cultural competence into the law school curriculum.
Public Action Work Group
Co-Chairs: Brandy Davis ‘22, Beth Farrell, Head of Library Access/Technical Services, Professor Ken Kowalski
Charge: Support and advocate for legislation, resolutions, and community actions that advance the cause of racial justice.
2020-21 Progress Report
- During the first full Work Group meeting on Sept 11, 2020 the group decided to devote our energies toward the Nov 3, 2020 election.
- Created an online Voting Resource Guide which was updated weekly with election information, virtual events, and in-person and virtual volunteer opportunities. The guide had over 300 views during the 8 weeks it was up on the law library website and featured in the October 9th American Association of Law Libraries KnowItALL, a daily national newsletter which highlights legal information, industry trends, law, technology, library, and career development topics.
- Sent out 2 emails to all law students: the first to inform students about on-campus voter registration and election worker volunteer sign ups and the second to ask students who had applied to be election officials to contact the co-chairs so we could expedite their applications with the Cuyahoga County Board of Elections. 15 student applications were expedited, and most students were confirmed as election officials.
- The Co-Chairs met several times with Judge Ronald Adrine to discuss how the group could best help local voting initiatives. Judge Adrine identified that transportation to the polls could be an issue in the city of Cleveland because local church groups and other organizations were not organizing bus trips to the Board of Elections (BOE) for early voting. We created a flyer describing two organizations offering free rides to the BOE, and contacted all churches in Cleveland as well as other Cleveland area service organizations. Work Group members shared this information, and other election/volunteer information, with their social networks.
- Worked with Associate Dean Sarah Beznoska to develop a series of panels designed to help students of color navigate diversity, inclusion, and bias issues in law school and their careers.
- Reached out to Marketing Director Elaine Terman about including contact information for student group leadership on the law school website (so potential employers can easily find contact information for groups, e.g. an employer looking to offer an internship to a student of color could easily find BLSA contact information.) We will work to get this information on the website after new student leadership is elected in the spring. The information will be on this page: https://www.law.csuohio.edu/currentstudents/studentorganizations
- During a meeting with Bar Exam Preparation Director Mary Jane McGinty and Professor Heidi Robertson to discuss supporting students of color taking the bar exam, we learned about the mentoring partnership with Norman S. Minor Bar Association. We will follow up with the Norman Minor Bar Association to learn more about this partnership. We hope to reach out to recent bar takers to learn what more can be done to help students of color with bar preparation.
- Reached out to the Federal Student Bar Association and discussed the opportunity to partner on several events with them.
- Worked with other work group co-chairs on developing the April 2021 Racial Equity and Social Justice Challenge.
- Participated in the review of proposals by three companies who provide organizations with diversity, equity, and inclusion training: Anti-Defamation League, Enlightened Solutions, and the Racial Equity Institute.
- Inform the C|M|LAW community about issues related to voting rights and to advocate for free and fair elections.
- Continue to explore how best to support law students of color as they prepare for the bar exam.
- Continue to explore partnerships with local organizations and employers to create equal opportunities for law students of color.
- Begin a series of panels designed to help students of color navigate diversity, inclusion, and bias issues in law school and their careers.
Community Conversations Work Group
Co-Chairs: Chuka Anyafo ‘22, Amy Miller, Director of Alumni & Donor Relations /Associate Director for Enrollment, Professor Pam Daiker-Middaugh
Charge: Develop programming to provide regular learning and conversation opportunities.
2020-21 Progress Report
- Created 9 programs in AY20-21; 5 in Fall 2020 and 4 in Spring 2021.
- Fall 2020: Partnered with Dean Fisher’s JEDI course to host the following forums: Racial Discrimination in Voting (September 24), Threats to Election 2020 (October 27), Employment Discrimination & Corporate Initiatives in Racial Equity (October 29), Health Disparities & Race (November 12), and Local Government & Racial and Social Justice (December 2)
- Spring 2021: Viewing of the film, The Mauritanian, & Panel Discussion (February 24), Disparities in COVID Vaccinations in Greater Cleveland (March 31), Law & Race: The Capitol Insurrection v. Black Lives Matter Protests (April 7), and Student Panel & Viewing the film, King in the Wilderness (April 23)
- Co-sponsored 5 programs in Spring 2021.
- Two co-sponsored by Racial Justice Community Conversations & Criminal Justice Forum: How Policing Reinforces Racial Segregation in the 21st Century (March 10) and Policing and “Bluelining” (April 26).
- Three co-sponsored by Racial Justice Community Conversations & Law School Name Committee: Facing and Confronting our History Forum (March 22), Guiding Principles for Naming an Institution (April 23), and The Legacy of Chief Justice John Marshall (April 27).
- Diversity of panelists has been an important initiative.
Of the 9 Racial Justice Community Conversations we created, there were a total of 28 panelists. 9 were Black women, 7 were Black men, 1 Hispanic man, 1 Asian man, 6 White women, and 4 White men.
Of the 5 co-sponsored programs (Criminal Justice Forum & Law School Name Committee), there were a total of 9 panelists. 2 Black women, 1 Asian woman, 1 White woman, and 5 White men.
- Hosted first Racial Justice Community Conversations Student Book Club. Students selected Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria? by Dr. Beverly Tatum, read over winter break, and a group of students met to discuss the book and their thoughts (February 23)
- Continue Racial Justice Community Conversations Student Book Club.
- Goals: (1) Select at least one book for the entire community to read over the summer and discuss in September 2021. (2) Select one book for students to read over winter break and discuss in January 2022.
- Racial Justice Film Series
- Goal: Host at least two movies and panel discussions in the Fall semester and once a month in the Spring semester. We will begin securing films and panels over the summer.
- We’ve had our first meeting of the Racial Justice Film Committee and members have submitted their film/documentary recommendations so we plan to make initial selections for Fall 2021 semester.
- Seek out program ideas, moderators, and speakers from our alumni, students, and faculty and staff to provide educational, relevant, and high-quality Racial Justice Community Conversations in Fall 2021 and Spring 2022.
We are fortunate to teach law at a law school where our university leadership understands and supports the need for CSU Cleveland-Marshall to be among those on the front lines of this fight. It’s who we are.
- We pledge to examine our own conscious and unconscious biases and how we can better stand in solidarity and alliance with communities of color and the disenfranchised.
- We commit to creating a community where all feel supported and valued. I encourage our students, faculty, and staff to engage in difficult conversations on equity, diversity, inclusion and racial justice with empathy. Let’s listen, truly listen, to the lived experiences of each other.
- We commit to spending the next upcoming academic year further deepening our collective understanding, identifying possible solutions, and taking effective action. We will continue to actively engage with our students, faculty, staff, and alumni, to listen and together determine the actions we must take.
Let us all follow the example of our 12 Racial Justice Work Group Co-Chairs and be JEDI Warriors.
May the force of justice be with you.
Stay safe. Stay healthy. Stay Committed to Living Justice.
Have a great day. Have a great week.
For copies of past messages, please go to this link: Monday Morning Messages.
Dean, Cleveland-Marshall College of Law | Cleveland State University
Joseph C. Hostetler-BakerHostetler
1801 Euclid Avenue, LB 138 |Cleveland, Ohio 44115 -2214